Coach, advisor, or app

Who should you hire for help with money?

A financial coach isn't the right answer for everyone. This page lays out the options side by side, including the cases where you should call someone else.

The short version.

An advisor manages what you've already saved. A coach works on everything that happens before that: what comes in, what goes out, what you owe, and the decisions and habits that determine whether there's anything left to invest. Apps track. Counseling agencies negotiate debt. Each is good at its own job.

Financial coach (50 Bar)Financial advisor or plannerBudgeting appNonprofit credit counseling
Best atBudgeting, debt, irregular income, habits, and decisions during a life changeInvesting, retirement accounts, and long-range wealth planningShowing you where money wentStructured repayment of unsecured debt
How they're usually paidFlat fee for sessions, posted on this siteA percentage of assets managed, commissions on products, a flat or hourly fee, or a mixSubscription, ads, or product referralsLow fees, plus funding from creditors in many cases
Sells productsNoSome do. Ask.Many promote cards and loansOffers debt management plans
Manages your investmentsNoYesNoNo
Talks through the why behind your spendingYes. It's a core part of the work.SometimesNoLimited
AccountabilityRegular check-ins with the same personPeriodic reviewsNotificationsMonthly payment schedule
Typical starting pointAny income, any balanceOften an asset minimumAnyonePeople struggling with card debt

Descriptions of other providers are general. Individual firms differ, so ask anyone you're considering how they're paid.

50 Bar is a good fit if

  • You want to understand your own numbers and not hand them off
  • Your income, household, or balance is about to change
  • You've tried budgeting apps and spreadsheets and they didn't stick
  • You and a partner need a neutral third person in the room
  • You're self-employed and your income is uneven
  • You want advice from someone with no stake in what you choose

Call someone else if

  • You want someone to pick and manage investments. That's a licensed investment advisor.
  • You need tax returns prepared or a tax strategy. That's a CPA or enrolled agent.
  • You need a will, a trust, or legal advice on a divorce or settlement. That's an attorney.
  • You're facing collections lawsuits or considering bankruptcy. Start with an attorney or a nonprofit credit counseling agency.

Coaching works well alongside any of these professionals. A coach helps you walk into those meetings knowing your numbers and your questions.

One question to ask anyone

"How do you get paid if I say yes?"

It's the most useful question in personal finance, and a good professional answers it without flinching. Katie's answer fits in one line.

This service is coaching, not sales. We do not sell any financial products and do not earn anything from what you do with your hard-earned money.

Her fees are on the plans page. That's the entire arrangement.

Not sure which you need? Ask.

Use the free 30 minutes to describe your situation. If a coach isn't the right call, Katie will point you toward the kind of professional who is.

Join the mailing list

A gauge check in your inbox.

Plain-language notes from Katie on budgeting, debt, and getting ready for windfalls and curveballs. No products and no pitches here either.